There is a video trend on YouTube of ranking various martial arts for how effective they are for self defense. I too have taken part in this trend, resulting in the most watched video on my YouTube channel. While comparing various content creators' opinions on the subject, a general consensus started to emerge. That consensus being that Combat Sports like Muay Thai, Lethwei, and Boxing were always put in the top tier, while more traditional martial arts like Karate, Kung Fu, Kali, and Kenpo were put in the mid to low tiers. The reasoning often given is the Combat Sports, because they are trying to knock each other out, give the practitioner a better sense of what a real fight feels like when compared to non-Combat Sports that tend to compete with lighter contact and more protective gear. The Idea seems simple enough, if you want to learn to fight then you should fight hard and fight often.
When I was in my 20s, I would agree with this sentiment wholeheartedly. I would take any fight I could get when I was in high school and college. Living in Mississippi in the early 2000s, formal Martial Arts competitions were not available to me. So, I took part in weekly fight clubs, did challenge matches, and sparred with local martial artists as often as I could. Now I know this is not the same kind of competition that a Muay Thai fighter or boxer is doing but believe me when I tell you we were fighting for real. In college I took up Boxing, did a little Muay Thai, and I attended a gym that sparred very hard! Why? Because if you were going to learn how to fight you had to do the real thing. Right?
According to the Indiana University School of Medicine “Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy, or CTE, is a progressive degenerative disease affecting people who have suffered repeated concussions and traumatic brain injuries that may occur in some athletes and others who have been exposed to concussions and repetitive head impacts.” The repeated blows and shocks to the brain associated with Combat Sports put fighters at an unusually high risk of developing CTE. This phenomenon is not exclusive to striking sports. Ronda Rousey, an Olympic bronze medalist in Judo and the first UFC women’s champion, admitted in her latest book “Our Fight” that she had sustained well over 100 concussions in Judo before she ever took part in striking arts.
According to the National Institute of Health, “CTE results in a progressive decline of memory and cognition, as well as depression, suicidal behavior, poor impulse control, aggressiveness, and eventually dementia similar to Alzheimer's disease.” These impairments can have a horrible effect on your quality of life as you age.
Combat Sports can also have a negative effect on the rest of your body as well. For example, the guy who taught me kickboxing was 60 years old and had cataracts, glaucoma, and was missing an ear from years of competing in the ring (granted he lost the ear in a bar fight). I am in my mid 30s at the time of writing this, and because of my years of doing fight clubs and challenge matches I have shoulder issues, back issues, and I can't straighten my elbows.
On the flip side one of my Kung Fu Instructors, Master Daniel Pesina, is in his 60s and in phenomenal shape. I once asked him how he does it, and he gave me a simple answer “Do Kung Fu every day”. Then there is my Sifu in Wing Chun, a man in his 70s who can still do pistol squats, swears by the practice of kung fu as his primary method to stay in shape. Finally, there is Guru Dan Inosanto who still travels around the world teaching Kali and Jeet Kune Do in his 80s. He tells me a combination of a good diet, restorative arts like yoga and physical therapy, and training martial arts is the key to his longevity.
I have trained with a lot of old men who can still do martial arts, and I have trained with a lot of middle-aged men whose bodies are falling apart. What is the difference between these two? What styles they study and how they train it. None of the guys who are 60+ prescribe to this “You have to get in the ring to learn to fight” philosophy. Instead, they encourage super light contact sparring and a lot of intense drilling of techniques. In contrast the instructors with broken bodies are all the dudes who tell me to do neck bridges, to always train as hard as I can, and are constantly pushing their students to compete in full contact martial arts tournaments.
But the question still remains, can the guys who don't train so hard still defend themselves? The answer is yes. I know of very few instances where a trained martial artist of any kind was unable to protect themselves against an untrained fighter. Because martial artist are always competing with each other we tend to forget that the 90+ percent of people who have never done martial arts can’t take a single punch or handle being thrown to the ground. Infact, they don't even know how to defend such counter attacks.
I once had a friend of mine attacked at a gas station. He never sparred hard and just practiced Kenpo twice a week. When the guy swung a punch at him, my friend snap kicked him in the groin, palm struck him in the face, and broke the guy's knee with a side kick. My friend never competed in boxing, he was a middle-aged man who smoked like a chimney and liked doing martial arts in his spare time. I assure you that if a Boxer or an MMA fighter had a fight with my buddy, my friend would lose. But that is fighting, not self-defense. His training had him fully prepared to protect himself and he did not have to incur a lifetime of brain trauma to develop the skill.
There is a concept in Wing Chun that instead of hitting as hard as we possibly can, which will most likely break our knuckles, we hit hard enough and accurately enough to get the job done. We do this to minimize the risk of injury to our hands. Many of the older martial arts styles, much like the older men who taught me, have developed a softer, more relaxed training method because they have found longevity is more important than speed of skill development. If you want to become the best fighter in the world, it is important to know there will be some major sacrifices you must make to your body and brain. However, if you are just wanting to learn to protect yourself, stay in shape, and get a good workout in, then the arts like Kung Fu, Jeet Kune Do, Kali, and Kenpo will also teach you how to fight and take care of your body as you do them. Much like the Wing Chun punch, it’s not about training as hard as you can. It’s about training hard enough and smart enough to get the job done and reach your goals without taking on long term damage to your brain or body.